After kidnapping Shaun Mars, the Origami Killer locks him in a drywell in the old warehouse, in which he will drown when it fills with rainwater. Ethan Mars, Norman Jayden, and Madison Paige can free Shaun if they find the warehouse, though Norman and Madison will have to fight the Origami Killer first.
- The old warehouse is located along the waterfront at 852 Theodore Roosevelt Road.
- Norman mentions in "Solving the Puzzle" that a retired police lieutenant (Scott Shelby) owns the warehouse.
- If Madison is the only playable character who arrives at the old warehouse, Shaun can still die if the player fails to perform her QTEs correctly when the Origami Killer arrives and confronts her.